I see you have not rated the twelve sherry cask mac. Me, I have in no way tried out the fine oaks. I should go there. My hesitation has always stemmed from the suspicion that I'd find the Mac fine oaks to be much too bitter. The Macallan/X (formerly Twitter) https://macallan-16-year26114.techionblog.com/31281123/the-lagavulin-16-vs-macallan-18-diaries